Browse Categories

~Cheeses and samplers

Cave-ripened Cheddar
Jonathan's truly traditional cheddar, cave-aged with a natural, bloomy rind
Cheese Samplers
Try a selection of our fine cheeses, sized to your needs. Our samplers make excellent gifts!
The "brie of Barbarossa", this soft-ripened wheel celebrates the pasture. Strong, fruity, and yeasty, this cheese is profoundly satisfying.
A semi-firm wheel with a complex flavor that varies with the changing seasons.
Frolic: firm, full-flavored wheel
A collaboration between Bobolink and three Amish graziers, this firm cheese has a sweet, nutty flavor, ending in a "tweak".
Made at Oasis at Bird-in-Hand, even folks who don't like blue cheese love this one!
Jean-Louis: our biggest wheel
This 22 lb (+-) wheel is named in honor of the memory of chef Jean-Louis Palladin, who encouraged food artisans to aim for bolder, earthier flavors.
Look here for seasonal cheeses, new releases, limited editions, and experimental cheeses. (to be kept updated on this category, please join our mailing list!)
Displaying products 1 - 4 of 4 results
Cave-Ripened Cheddar, 1 lb cut
Price: $24.00
Cave-Ripened Cheddar, 1 lb cut
Aged approximately 15 months, this cheddar has a full, mellow, complex, and compelling flavor. Made in collaboration with an Amish cheesemaker, it is made from the raw milk of 100% grass-fed cows. The natural rind is delicious!
tax free
Cave-Ripened Cheddar, 1/2 lb cut
Price: $12.00
Cave-Ripened Cheddar, 1/2  lb cut
Aged approximately 15 months, this cheddar has a full, mellow, complex, and compelling flavor. Made in collaboration with an Amish cheesemaker, it is made from the raw milk of 100% grass-fed cows. The natural rind is delicious!
tax free
Amish Blue Cheese 1/2lb
Price: $15.00
Amish Blue Cheese 1/2lb
Made by our Amish friends at Oasis Cooperative
tax free
5 year Extra Reserve Cheddar, 1/2 lb cut
Price: $15.00
5 year Extra Reserve Cheddar, 1/2  lb cut
This spectacular cheese was made by our colleagues at Oasis at Bird-in-Hand. It is 5 years old, with beautiful crystallization. Yes, it's strong, sharp, and you'll come back for more! Excellent for cooking, too!
tax free
Shopping Cart
Your cart is empty.