Browse Categories

Cave-ripened Cheddar

This cheddar has a full, creamy, warm flavor that lingers sweetly. Try it on its own, or add it to your favorite recipe. We usually only use half the quantity that recipes recommend, because the flavor is so full!

Cheeses and meats will be shipped in separate boxes, as the products have different packaging requirements. We will contact you with the actual shipping cost after your order is placed.
Displaying products 1 - 5 of 5 results
Cave-Ripened Cheddar, 1 lb cut
Price: $24.00
Cave-Ripened Cheddar, 1 lb cut
Aged approximately 15 months, this cheddar has a full, mellow, complex, and compelling flavor. Made in collaboration with an Amish cheesemaker, it is made from the raw milk of 100% grass-fed cows. The natural rind is delicious!
tax free
Cave-Ripened Cheddar, 1/2 lb cut
Price: $12.00
Cave-Ripened Cheddar, 1/2  lb cut
Aged approximately 15 months, this cheddar has a full, mellow, complex, and compelling flavor. Made in collaboration with an Amish cheesemaker, it is made from the raw milk of 100% grass-fed cows. The natural rind is delicious!
tax free
5 year Extra Reserve Cheddar, 1/2 lb cut
Price: $15.00
5 year Extra Reserve Cheddar, 1/2  lb cut
This spectacular cheese was made by our colleagues at Oasis at Bird-in-Hand. It is 5 years old, with beautiful crystallization. Yes, it's strong, sharp, and you'll come back for more! Excellent for cooking, too!
tax free
Cave-ripened Cheddar quarter-block (2.5 lb approx)
Price: $55.00
Cave-ripened Cheddar  quarter-block (2.5 lb approx)
Aged approximately 15 months, this cheddar has a full, mellow, complex, and compelling flavor. Made in collaboration with an Amish cheesemaker, it is made from the raw milk of 100% grass-fed cows. The natural rind is delicious!
tax free
Cave-ripened Cheddar half-block (5 lb approx)
Price: $110.00
Cave-ripened Cheddar  half-block (5 lb approx)
Aged approximately 15 months, this cheddar has a full, mellow, complex, and compelling flavor. Made in collaboration with an Amish cheesemaker, it is made from the raw milk of 100% grass-fed cows. The natural rind is delicious!
tax free
Shopping Cart
Your cart is empty.